By Bamidele Kolawole

|

In the healthcare sector, the relationship between patients and medical practitioners is fundamentally built on trust. Patients entrust their lives and health to professionals who are expected to act with the highest standards of care and diligence. However, instances of medical negligence that result in harm to patients threaten this sacred trust.

Medical negligence, a critical aspect of tort law, arises when a healthcare professional fails to provide the standard of care reasonably expected, leading to injury or harm to a patient. In Nigeria, this area of law has been shaped by statutes, judicial pronouncements, and common law principles, providing various remedies to aggrieved patients.

Understanding Medical Negligence in Nigerian Law

Medical negligence is actionable under the tort of negligence, which requires the plaintiff to establish three critical elements:

Duty of Care: The healthcare provider owes the patient a duty of care.

Breach of Duty: There was a failure to meet the required standard of care.

Causation and Damages: The breach resulted in injury or harm to the patient.

The Nigerian courts often rely on common law principles and judicial precedents from other jurisdictions to determine these elements.

Key Statutes and Regulations

The Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended): The right to life (Section 33) and the right to human dignity (Section 34) impose a duty on healthcare providers to ensure the safety and well-being of patients.

National Health Act, 2014: This Act sets out the responsibilities of healthcare providers, including ensuring the quality and standards of medical care.

Code of Medical Ethics in Nigeria: Published by the Medical and Dental Council of Nigeria (MDCN), this code provides guidelines for professional conduct and standards of medical practice.

Conclusion

Medical negligence law in Nigeria provides a framework for holding healthcare providers accountable and compensating victims. However, greater public awareness, improved judicial processes, and stricter enforcement of ethical standards are needed to strengthen the regime. Through continued judicial interpretation and legislative reform, Nigeria can ensure that patients receive the justice they deserve while fostering a culture of professionalism within the medical sector.

Medical negligence arises when a healthcare provider breaches their duty of care to a patient, resulting in harm or injury. This legal issue is governed by tort law, with elements of contract law in certain circumstances. In this article, we examine the concept of medical negligence, the remedies available to patients, and the legal regime underpinning such claims.

Medical negligence involves the failure of a medical professional to provide care that meets established standards. To establish negligence, a patient (plaintiff) must prove:

Duty of Care: The healthcare provider owed a duty to the patient.

Breach of Duty: The provider failed to meet the standard of care expected in similar circumstances.

Causation: The breach caused harm to the patient.

Damages: The patient suffered quantifiable harm or loss as a result.

Legal Remedies Available to Patients

Compensation (Damages)

Patients harmed by medical negligence can claim monetary compensation to address physical, emotional, and financial harm.

General Damages: For pain, suffering, and loss of enjoyment of life.

Special Damages: For quantifiable losses, including medical expenses, loss of earnings, and future care costs.

Punitive Damages: Awarded in rare cases of gross negligence or intentional harm to punish the offender and deter similar conduct.

Declaratory Relief

Patients may seek a court declaration that the healthcare provider was negligent. This is often the basis for pursuing further remedies.

Injunctive Relief

In cases where negligence is ongoing or likely to recur, a court may issue an injunction to prevent the continuation of harmful practices.

 Apology and Professional Sanctions

Some jurisdictions mandate that negligent healthcare providers apologize to the patient. Professional bodies, such as medical councils, may also impose sanctions, including fines, suspension, or revocation of licenses.

Restitution

Patients may request restitution to restore them to their prior position as far as possible, including corrective surgeries or treatments.

Legal Framework for Medical Negligence Claims

Tort Law

Medical negligence claims are primarily grounded in tort law, focusing on compensating victims for harm caused by a breach of duty. The “Bolam Test” and the “reasonable person” standard often guide courts in determining the adequacy of medical care.

Contract Law

In some cases, patients may have claims under contract law, particularly where a healthcare provider fails to deliver services as agreed.

Medical negligence refers to the failure of a healthcare provider to exercise the appropriate standard of care in treating a patient, resulting in harm or injury. This concept is crucial in understanding the legal remedies available to patients who have suffered due to such negligence. The legal regime surrounding medical negligence encompasses various avenues for redress, which can be pursued by aggrieved patients.

To establish a case of medical negligence, three essential elements must be demonstrated: the existence of a legal duty of care owed by the healthcare provider to the patient, a breach of that duty, and damages suffered as a direct result of that breach. The duty of care implies that medical practitioners are expected to provide adequate counseling, warn patients about potential side effects and risks of treatment, conduct proper diagnoses, administer appropriate treatments, and obtain informed consent from patients before proceeding with any medical intervention.

When a patient believes they have been harmed due to medical negligence, they have several options for seeking remedies. One primary avenue is through civil litigation. Patients can file a lawsuit against the healthcare provider or institution for damages resulting from the alleged negligence. This process requires the patient to prove that the healthcare provider failed to meet the requisite standard of care and that this failure directly caused their injuries. In Nigeria, for instance, patients can approach the High Court to claim damages for negligence.

In addition to civil claims, patients may also lodge complaints with regulatory bodies such as the Medical and Dental Council. This body has the authority to investigate complaints against practitioners and impose sanctions if they find evidence of professional misconduct or gross negligence. Possible actions include suspending a practitioner’s license or striking their name off the register entirely.

Criminal law also plays a role in addressing severe cases of medical negligence. If a healthcare provider’s actions are deemed grossly negligent—showing a reckless disregard for patient safety—criminal charges may be pursued. This could lead to penalties including imprisonment. The Nigerian Criminal Code stipulates that any person administering medical treatment must do so with reasonable skill and care; failure to do so can result in criminal liability.

Moreover, patients may seek alternative remedies through breach of contract claims. The relationship between a doctor and a patient is often considered contractual; thus, if a practitioner fails to uphold their end of this implied contract by not providing competent care, the patient may have grounds for a breach of contract claim. This approach can be particularly useful in cases where proving negligence is challenging.

In summary, the legal regime surrounding medical negligence provides multiple avenues for patients seeking redress. These include civil lawsuits for damages, complaints to regulatory bodies for professional misconduct, and potential criminal charges for gross negligence. Understanding these options is vital for patients who wish to hold medical practitioners accountable and ensure that standards of care are upheld within the healthcare system.

In cases of medical negligence, patients who fall victim do have various legal remedies available to them in various forms, such as;

Civil Remedies:

Lawsuit: Patients can file a lawsuit against the healthcare provider, hospital, or medical professional for damages resulting from medical negligence.

Damages: Patients can seek compensation for economic losses (e.g., medical expenses, lost wages) and non-economic losses (e.g., pain, suffering, emotional distress).

Punitive Damages: In some cases, patients may be entitled to punitive damages, which aim to punish the healthcare provider for reckless or intentional behavior.

Administrative Remedies

Complaint to Medical Boards: Patients can file a complaint with the state medical board, which can investigate and discipline the healthcare provider.

Complaint to the Specific Hospital Management: Patients can file a complaint with the hospital or healthcare facility, which can lead to an internal investigation and potential disciplinary action.

Complaint to Medical Association: Patients can file a complaint with the Nigerian Medical Association 

Complaint with the Human Right Groups, which is a non-profit organization.

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR);

Mediation: Patients can participate in mediation, a process where a neutral third-party facilitates a discussion between the patient and healthcare provider to resolve the dispute.

Arbitration: Patients can agree to arbitration, a process where a neutral third-party makes a binding decision.

The civil Suit can be premised on Statutory Enactments for Remedies.

Patient Safety Laws: Some states have enacted patient safety laws, which provide specific protections and remedies for patients.

Healthcare Consumer Protection Laws: Some states have enacted healthcare consumer protection laws, which provide remedies for patients who have been harmed by healthcare providers.

Other Remedies;

Apology and Explanation: Patients may seek an apology and explanation from the healthcare provider.

In conclusion, victims of Medical Negligence or their family members should avoid taking Law into their hands.

Medical negligence, also known as medical malpractice, occurs when a healthcare provider fails to meet the standard of care expected in their profession, resulting in harm or injury to a patient. In Nigeria, medical negligence can lead to civil and criminal liability.

Here are the elements of Medical Negligence:

The healthcare provider owes a duty of care to the patient; the healthcare provider fails to meet the standard of care expected in the medical profession; and the breach of duty causes harm or injury to the patient. Aggrieved party or patient would show he/she suffers harm or injury as a result of the breach of duty.

In Nigerian civil courts, patients can seek monetary compensation as damages for medical negligence.

The Nigerian criminal law stipulates that healthcare practitioners can face prosecution for medical negligence under various circumstances involving negligent acts causing harm or death.

The principle of “res ipsa loquitur” which establishes the injury or harm is so obvious that it is assumed to be a result of medical negligence and the Bolam test are used to determine the reasonable standard a healthcare provider should adopt in treating patients.

Medical negligence can have severe consequences for healthcare personnel and patients can seek redress through civil and criminal courts. The healthcare providers must adhere to the standard of care expected in their profession to avoid liability.

However, patients have the right to receive accurate and complete information about their medical condition, treatment options, and potential risks and benefits while retaining the right to expect that their medical information will be kept confidential and only shared with authorized individuals and treated with dignity and respect, regardless of their medical condition or personal characteristics.

Medical law holds healthcare personnel liable for medical negligence, including failure to diagnose, improper treatment, and surgical errors.

The law also recognize patients’ rights, including the right to autonomy, dignity, and respect as well as regulating the healthcare profession, including licensing requirements, continuing education, and disciplinary action.

The Nigerian Constitution and the National Health Act provides a framework for healthcare delivery in Nigeria, including provisions for patient rights and medical law. Also the Medical and Dental Practitioners Act regulates the practice of medicine and dentistry in Nigeria.

Be that as it may, some patients are not aware of their rights and responsibilities under our extant medical laws and should seek redress in the appropriate court or tribunal.

In the healthcare sector, the relationship between patients and medical practitioners is fundamentally built on trust. Patients entrust their lives and health to professionals who are expected to act with the highest standards of care and diligence. However, instances of medical negligence errors or omissions that result in harm to patients threaten this sacred trust. 

Understanding Medical Negligence 

Medical negligence occurs when a healthcare professional breaches the duty of care owed to a patient, resulting in injury, exacerbation of an illness, or even death. Examples include misdiagnosis, surgical errors, medication mistakes, and failure to provide timely treatment. In Nigeria, medical negligence has gained increased attention as awareness of patient rights continues to grow. 

 Legal Framework Addressing Medical Negligence 

Under Nigerian law, remedies for medical negligence are rooted in tort law, contract law, and criminal law. 

Tort of Negligence: To establish a case, a patient must prove that the healthcare provider owed a duty of care, breached this duty, and caused damage or injury directly resulting from this breach. 

Contractual Liability: Patients may also pursue claims based on a breach of implied terms in the doctor-patient relationship, such as the obligation to exercise reasonable skill and care. 

Criminal Liability: In extreme cases where gross negligence leads to death, practitioners can face criminal prosecution under laws like the Criminal Code Act or the Penal Code Act. 

Available Remedies for Victims of Medical Negligence 

Victims of medical negligence in Nigeria have access to several remedies, including: 

Compensation through Civil Litigation: Patients can file lawsuits seeking damages for physical, emotional, and financial losses. Courts may award compensatory or punitive damages based on the severity of the harm. 

Redress through Professional Bodies: Complaints can be lodged with regulatory bodies like the Medical and Dental Council of Nigeria (MDCN). The MDCN has the authority to investigate and sanction erring practitioners, including suspending or revoking licenses. 

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR): Given the lengthy court processes in Nigeria, ADR mechanisms such as mediation and arbitration offer quicker resolution for disputes. 

Health Insurance Complaints Channels: For patients covered under the National Health Insurance Authority (NHIA) scheme, grievances may be addressed through the NHIA’s complaint channels. 

Challenges in Seeking Remedies 

Despite these legal avenues, victims often encounter significant hurdles in pursuing remedies: 

Lack of Awareness: Many patients are unaware of their rights or the process for seeking redress. 

Cost of Litigation: Legal proceedings can be expensive, discouraging patients from filing claims. 

Delayed Justice: Court cases often drag on for years due to procedural bottlenecks. 

Fear of Retaliation: Patients may hesitate to file complaints against influential hospitals or practitioners. 

Enhancing Access to Justice 

To ensure better protection for patients, there is a need for: 

Awareness Campaigns: Educating the public on patient rights and available remedies. 

Strengthening the MDCN: Empowering the council to promptly address negligence cases and enforce disciplinary measures. 

Improved Legal Frameworks: Reforming laws to streamline litigation processes and enhance compensation mechanisms. 

Government Oversight: Regular audits of healthcare facilities to ensure compliance with safety standards. 

Conclusion 

Medical negligence not only undermines public confidence in the healthcare system but also causes irreparable harm to victims and their families. By leveraging legal frameworks and strengthening institutional responses, Nigeria can create a more accountable healthcare system where patients receive the justice and care they deserve. 

Medical negligence, as a ground or cause of action can touch on the performance of a diversity of healthcare providers such as nurses, pharmacists, anaesthetists, laboratory technologists, physiotherapists and so on (Odunsi, 2008) . By extension, it can also vicariously affect the employers of caregivers, as is usually the case.

Medical negligence occurs when a healthcare professional fails to provide the standard of care expected, leading to patient harm. The legal framework governing remedies for medical negligence varies by jurisdiction but generally includes several legal and administrative options. 

Civil Remedies (Tort Law).

Patients can file a civil lawsuit for compensation under tort law, specifically for: 

– Medical Malpractice Claims: The patient must prove duty of care, breach of duty, causation, and damages. 

– Compensation Types:

 – Special Damages: For actual financial losses (medical bills, loss of income). 

 – General Damages: For non-economic losses like pain, suffering, and emotional distress. 

Criminal Liability.

In cases involving gross negligence or willful misconduct, criminal charges such as manslaughter may be filed against healthcare providers. Criminal sanctions include fines, imprisonment, and professional license revocation.

Disciplinary Actions.

Patients can file complaints with medical regulatory bodies or professional councils. These bodies can impose penalties such as license suspension, fines, or practice restrictions on negligent professionals. 

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)

– Mediation and Arbitration: These methods provide faster and less costly dispute resolution outside the court system. 

– Healthcare Ombudsman Services: In some countries, patients can seek help from healthcare ombudsmen to resolve disputes informally. 

Challenges in Seeking Remedies

– Proving negligence can be complex due to the need for expert testimony. 

– Legal costs and lengthy court procedures may deter patients from pursuing claims.

Doctors face the challenge of balancing patient care with legal risks, which can create conflicts between medical duties and legal liability. Fear of litigation may lead doctors to view patients as potential legal threats or prioritize self-protection over patient and public welfare.

Addressing these issues requires collaboration between legal and medical professionals to ensure fair outcomes in medical negligence cases.